For Vacation Rental Questions Contact Cayman Oltersdorf Email: rentals@oltersdorf.com | Call/Text: 231-218-8892
  • Our Listings
  • Vacation Rentals
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Menu

Oltersdorf Realty - Leelanau County & Traverse City Real Estate

Leelanau County & Traverse City Real Estate
  • Our Listings
  • Vacation Rentals
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Our Suttons Bay Area & Leelanau County Vacation Rentals!
Click on a rental for additional information!

prev / next
Back to Vacation Rentals
7150 N West Bay Shore Drive, Northport, MI – Grand Traverse Bay Waterfront Vacation Rental - Oltersdorf Realty LLC (1).jpg
0
UP TO 16 GUESTS – 7150 N West Bay Shore Drive, Northport, MI – Grand Traverse Bay Vacation Rental
4651 E Tall Cedar Trail, Lake Leelanau Vacation Rental Waterfront- 1 (1).jpg
0
UP TO 8 GUESTS - 4651 E Tall Cedar Trl, Lake Leelanau, MI – North Lake Leelanau Vacation Rental
1.jpg
0
UP TO 6 GUESTS – Leland, MI – North Lake Leelanau Waterfront Vacation Rental
1497 S Nanagosa Trail, Suttons Bay Waterfront Vacation Rental by Oltersdorf Realty.JPG
0
SLEEPS 8 – 1497 S Nanagosa Trail, Suttons Bay, MI – West Bay Waterfront Vacation Rental
Lee Point Road - Suttons Bay Vacation Rental, Oltersdorf Realty (1).jpg
0
SLEEPS 6 – 3711 S Lee Point Road, Suttons Bay, MI– West Bay Waterfront Rental
400 N Nanagosa Trail, Suttons Bay, MI – Waterfront Vacation Rental.JPG
0
UP TO 6 GUESTS - 400 N Nanagosa Trail, Suttons Bay, MI - West Bay Waterfront Rental
114 N Lincoln, Suttons Bay, MI.jpg
0
UP TO 8 GUESTS - 114 N Lincoln, Suttons Bay, MI - Two blocks to Downtown!
1.jpeg
0
UP TO 6 GUESTS – 10892 East Murray Court, Suttons Bay, MI – Suttons Bay Vacation Rental
311 N St Josephs St, Suttons Bay, MI, Village of Suttons Bay Short Term Vacation Rental by Oltersdorf Realty, Vicky and Jonathan Oltersdorf, Leelanau County and Suttons Bay Realtors (1).jpg
0
UP TO 2 GUESTS - 311 N St Josephs St, Suttons Bay, MI - Downtown Suttons Bay Vacation Rental

FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA!

View fullsize JUST SOLD | $425,000 - 10829 N Shore Dr, Northport, MI – Unique Octagon Home on 1.61 Acres in the Village of Northport! Listed by Jonathan & Vicky Oltersdorf. Selling Agent: Vicky Oltersdorf . . . . #leelanaurealestate #leelanaurealtors #oc
View fullsize JUST SOLD ON 5/15/26- Off Market Deal - Sold by Vicky & Jonathan Oltersdorf - 1564 N West Bay Shore Drive, Suttons Bay, MI – 3 Bedroom Ranch with 275’ of Sandy Private Frontage on Suttons Bay! 😍🏖️. . . . . #suttonsbay #leelanau #le
View fullsize JUST SOLD in Silver Farms, Traverse City | $710,000 Ask Price – 3378 Silver Farms, Traverse City, MI – 3 Bedroom, 3.5 Bath, 3,100 sq ft 2 story home on 0.60 acres in Silver Farms, close to Downtown Traverse City!!! Buyer Agent -> Jonat
View fullsize
View fullsize OUR NEW LISTING | $1,850,000 - 3784 S Lee Point Road, Suttons Bay, MI – Ranch Home with 200’ of Private Pristine Sandy Bottom Beach on West Bay! Visit Oltersdorf.com or call Vicky & Jonathan at 231-271-7777 for more info!
View fullsize OUR NEW LISTING | $350,000 – 11.31 Acres – E Smiseth Road, Suttons Bay, MI – Exceptionally rare large-acreage parcel within the Village of Suttons Bay, backing directly to 20 acres of Village-owned parkland (Bahle Park)! Contact Jon
View fullsize OUR NEW LISTING | $559,000 - 7196 S West Bay Shore Drive, Traverse City, MI – 3 Bedroom Home with Extensive Updates & Beautiful Landscaping! Visit Oltersdorf.com or call 231-271-7777 for more info!
View fullsize OUR NEW LISTING | $398,500 - 10829 N Shore Dr, Northport, MI – Unique Octagon Home on 1.61 Acres in the Village of Northport! Visit Oltersdorf.com or call 231-271-7777 for more info. . . . . #leelanaurealestate #leelanaurealtors #octagon #octag
View fullsize OUR NEW LISTING | $139,500 – 2164 N Belanger Creek Drive, Suttons Bay, MI – 1.84 Acre Creekside Building Site! Visit Oltersdorf.com or Contact Vicky for more info: 231-632-1800. . . . . . . #ForSale #SuttonsBay #BelangerCreek #Leelanau #S
View fullsize OUR NEW LISTING | $198,500 – 2171 N Belanger Creek Drive, Suttons Bay, MI – 2.05 Acre Creekside Building Site! Visit Oltersdorf.com or Contact Vicky for more info: 231-632-1800. . . . . . . #ForSale #SuttonsBay #BelangerCreek #Leelanau #S
View fullsize OUR NEW LISTING | $89,400 – 2155 N Belanger Creek Drive, Suttons Bay, MI – 1.29 Acre Water View Lot! Visit Oltersdorf.com or Contact Vicky for more info: 231-632-1800. . . . . . . #ForSale #SuttonsBay #BelangerCreek #Leelanau #SuttonsBay
View fullsize OUR NEW LISTING | $210,000 – 1881 N Blue Water Ct, Suttons Bay, MI – Panoramic Water View Lot! Visit Oltersdorf.com for more info or call 231-271-7777!
View fullsize JUST SOLD in Downtown Traverse City | $505,000 - 1101 Jefferson Ave, Traverse City, MI – 2 Bedroom Ranch on an Oversized 195’ x 50’ Downtown Lot! Listing Agent --> Jonathan Oltersdorf . . . . . . #TraverseCity #TraverseCityRealEs
View fullsize Why Vacant Land Is Becoming Hard to Find in Leelanau County 👇Scroll for 4 data charts -> Leelanau County’s vacant land inventory didn’t get tight by accident. For most of the past 15 years, very few large-scale new developments wer
View fullsize 📊 Less than half of Leelanau County homes are occupied year-round — and that hasn’t changed much in 15 years. This chart shows the Principal Residence Exemption (PRE) trend from 2010–2025, a key indicator of how many properties ar
View fullsize 2025–2026 Leelanau County Home Inventory: Why Low Supply Is Still Defining the Market As of January 29, 2026, there are just 55 homes for sale in the entire county — that’s roughly a ±2-month supply. For context: • A b
View fullsize What did Leelanau County homebuyers actually buy in 2025—and where did the money go? Here’s the short version 👇 🏡 21% waterfront, 13% condo's, 12% water view, 10% 5+ acres.... 🌊 Waterfront still mattered… just not as much as yo
View fullsize 💰 Cash or financing? Leelanau County Home Sales in 2025: How 375 Buyers purchased their home-> 📊 375 home sales in 2025 🏦 55% financed 💵 45% cash 📉 Avg 30-yr rate: 6.60% Cash still matters, but financed buyers are very much back. If you&rsq
View fullsize Where did 2025 Leelanau County homebuyers come from? 📍--> scroll for more data and visit Oltersdorf.com/blog Short answer: not just from here. In 2025, there were 375 total homebuyers in Leelanau County. Only 43% came from Leelanau or Grand Tr
View fullsize 📊 **Leelanau County Real Estate | 2025 Year-End Update** Unlike Grand Traverse County, this market didn't level off. Leelanau County real estate continues to out perform. 🏡 **Homes Sold:** 375 ➡️ Up **+10.95%** from 2024 💰 **Total Sales Volume

Copyright © 2026, Oltersdorf Realty, LLC. All rights reserved. 231-271-7777 | realestate@oltersdorf.com | The information contained on this website has been furnished by our Seller’s and/or other sources. Every effort has been made to provide accurate information but we are unable to guarantee any information and recommend that the purchaser verify all information before closing.